U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh rejected Apple’s bid for a permanent injunction against Samsung, according to a Wednesday night ruling from U.S. District Court in San Jose. Apple had won a $120 million judgment against Samsung for infringing on three Apple patents, according to Koh’s ruling (case No. 12-CV-00630-LHK). But Koh on Wednesday declined to stop Samsung from selling its products with features infringing on the patents. “Apple has not satisfied its burden of demonstrating irreparable harm and linking that harm to Samsung’s exploitation of any of Apple’s three infringed patents,” she said. “Apple has not established that it suffered significant harm in the form of either lost sales or reputational injury.” Koh said she didn’t think Apple proved “that the patented inventions drive consumer demand for the infringing products.” Apple didn’t comment. A Samsung spokeswoman welcomed the ruling: “We remain committed to providing American consumers with a wide choice of innovative products."
Americans are more comfortable having an in-person conversation about the government’s surveillance programs than via a social media platform, said a Pew Research Internet Project report released Tuesday (http://pewrsr.ch/1BYLb3Q). In a survey of 1,801 adults, Pew asked about individuals’ willingness to discuss the surveillance programs that came to light in 2013. Eighty-six percent of those surveyed said they would have an in-person conversation about the topic, but only 42 percent of Facebook and Twitter users said they would post about it on either platform. “Social media did not provide new forums for those who might otherwise remain silent to express their opinions and debate issues,” said a summary of the report. “Further, if people thought their friends and followers in social media disagreed with them, they were less likely to say they would state their views on the Snowden-NSA story online and in other contexts, such as gatherings of friends, neighbors, or co-workers.”
The automotive telematics market is projected to grow to $45 billion by 2019, a MarketsandMarkets report found. Telematics, the technology that transfers data between vehicles or devices through wireless networks, has the potential to convert vehicles “from just a simple mode of transportation to moving information stations,” said the report, released Friday (http://bit.ly/1mvOd5C). Demand for connected vehicles is driven by developments like collision warnings or remote maintenance “that provide safety and comfort to the driver and passengers,” it said. Telematics services are divided into the four major types of safety, information and navigation, entertainment and remote diagnostics, MarketsandMarkets said.
The FCC Wireless and Wireline bureaus gave limited, interim relief to Alaska telco Adak Eagle Enterprises and its Windy City Cellular subsidiary Thursday. An order said Adak will receive $33,276 monthly and Windy City will receive $40,104 monthly. That funding will last no more than six months or until the commission reviews the companies’ petition for reconsideration (http://bit.ly/1tpZLfD). Adak and Windy City had petitioned the FCC for reconsideration of its denial of the companies’ request for a waiver of caps on USF payments (CD Aug 16/13 p5). Executives from Adak and Windy City urged FCC staff in a meeting last month to provide a “permanent solution” the funding issues they have sought to relieve through the waiver (CD July 29 p14).
Radar will remain a key technology in the automotive space, but camera sensors and machine vision technology are poised to push advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) into the mainstream due to low cost, flexibility and multiple use cases, said ABI Research. Automotive camera sensor shipments are forecast to reach 197 million by 2020 from suppliers including OmniVision, ON Semiconductor, Sony, STMicroelectronics and Toshiba, it said. ABI described a “fusion of sensors” combining with radar for forward-looking obstacle detection, pedestrian detection, lane guidance and driver monitoring; with infrared cameras for night vision; and with ultrasonic sensors for automated parking. Advances in RF transceivers, microcontrollers and open platforms will lead to cost reduction by leveraging microcontrollers across multiple sensors, it said. The primary driver for the uptake of ADAS will be the arrival of autonomous driving, ABI said. ADAS is already becoming the subject of regulation, with the European New Car Assessment Programme including the presence of speed assistance systems, autonomous emergency braking and lane departure warning/lane keep assist as criteria to determine safety ratings, it said. In the U.S., similar initiatives are being discussed by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which recently proposed changes to its five-star safety program, ABI said.
Applications for rural broadband experiment funding are due Oct. 14, the FCC Wireline Bureau said in a public notice Tuesday (http://fcc.us/1ti1vs9). The FCC is awarding up to $100 million in rural broadband experiment support (CD July 14 p11) to bring next generation voice and broadband service to high-cost areas of the country, the notice said. The budget calls for $75 million for projects in high-cost areas proposing to offer broadband service at 25 Mbps downstream and 5 Mbps upstream; $15 million for projects in high-cost areas proposing to offer broadband service of 10 Mbps downstream and 1 Mbps upstream; and $10 million for projects proposing to serve extremely high-cost areas with broadband service of 10 Mbps downstream and 1 Mbps upstream, the notice said.
The special access data collection effort announced by the FCC (CD Aug 19 p2) Monday could pose “longer-term concern for incumbent telcos,” said Paul Gallant, analyst at Guggenheim Partners, Wednesday in a research note. Noting the issue “has gone on for years,” Gallant wrote, “there is no assurance that it will actually result in rule changes. But should the FCC decide the data show incumbent pricing power and insufficient competition in certain areas, we do expect the agency to push forward with changes that could limit telcos’ special access prices in some way.” A final ruling is a ways off and “seems unlikely” before the first quarter of 2016, he said. Gallant said the FCC and congressional Democrats have long backed a special access inquiry, so Chairman Tom Wheeler will likely “closely evaluate whether to propose revised special access pricing rules for incumbent telcos.” What ultimately happens, he said, will depend on what the data show. If the findings are “inconclusive or not persuasive, the agency might decide that opening up a new policy battle with AT&T, Verizon, CenturyLink and others doesn’t pass the cost-benefit test,” Gallant wrote.
The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform is investigating the Patent and Trademark Office based on a Washington Post article (http://wapo.st/1oVE7Po) alleging USPTO remote employees lied about their hours, said a letter from committee Chairman Darrell Issa, R-Calif., to Commerce Secretary Penny Pritzker Tuesday (http://1.usa.gov/1thQ4Rl). “Reportedly, patent officers and paralegals routinely lied about their work and logged thousands of hours on the taxpayer’s dime,” said a committee news release Wednesday (http://1.usa.gov/VEMa8e). “Raising questions about USPTO’s internal investigation, the USPTO also removed the most damaging reports of employee fraud in a report to the agency’s independent watchdog.” Issa asked Pritzker to arrange a briefing by Friday for the committee’s staff. “We are carefully reviewing the Committee’s request and will respond and remain in close contact with the Committee on this matter,” the USPTO said in a statement Wednesday. The office “welcomes this opportunity to demonstrate that the agency’s award-winning telework programs -- and their measurable work production requirements for patent examiners -- have been integral to the USPTO’s dramatic, quantifiable progress in fulfilling its core functions of reducing the backlog of patent applications and the wait time for applicants,” it said.
One in four U.S. broadband homes with smart home devices experiences problems on a monthly basis, said research from Parks Associates, which plans a webcast Wednesday at 2 p.m. EDT to address service and support issues with smart devices in connected homes. “Internet of Things: Impact on Support Services & Solutions” is being held jointly with Support.com. “The dramatic shift in technology driven by the cloud and the Internet of Things increases product and call complexity,” said Amy Millard, Support.com vice president-marketing, in a Parks news release Monday (http://bit.ly/1rO08Pe). Technology providers have to “continuously optimize their service interactions,” Millard said, saying automating agent processes “is a key step” toward optimization.
While no final decisions likely have been made, the FCC appears unlikely to reclassify broadband as a Title II service, Paul Gallant, analyst at Guggenheim Partners, said Friday in a research note. “We don’t believe any final decisions have been made, but we continue to believe the most likely outcome is for the FCC to keep broadband classified under Title 1 and adopt rules that clearly restrict paid prioritization.” That would likely be the preference of Chairman Tom Wheeler, and few big Internet companies are pressing for reclassification, he wrote. Meanwhile, MIT Media Lab founder Nicholas Negroponte said in a video blog post he questions whether net neutrality rules make sense (http://bit.ly/1sJQZeH). All bits are not equal, he said. “People don’t appreciate that a book, a normal novel, is about a megabyte,” he said. “And yet a second of video is more than a megabyte. So when you look at video for a couple of hours it’s the equivalent of hundreds of books.”